California has been extremely hot this week, and nothing was as hot as Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince (HP&HBP). Potter fans from around the US lined up to watch the newest installment of HP and I was one of them. I didn’t go on opening night, which may shock some of you, and I did enjoy the sixth installment of the series.
Harry Potter and The Half-Blood Prince
For those who have read the books this movie holds no surprises, thankfully. The Harry Potter books have sparked debate, outrage, and a general sense of excitement ever since the first book came out. This movie is no exception to the mania that surrounds J.K. Rawlings’ creation. On a side note, people here just don’t get that into movies. Seattle was much more exuberant about summer blockbusters. Here, to their shame, there were no people dressed up as wizards, no long lines, not even an “Muggle’s just don’t understand” shirt at the Pasadena Paseo 16. It must have something to do with a tall, non-fat, Carmel Macciatto with extra-foam, and one packet of equal added for taste. Well, despite the lack of devoted fans on their 20th viewing, at the 9am Friday showing, it was still fun for Sonja and me.
For a person who has read the books, more than once, HP&HBP is sort of like a bag of Bertie Bott’s Every Flavor Beans one moment it is a wonderful spectacle and everything you could hope for, but in another something seems just a little off, like a puke flavored bean. I know that it is impossible to fit everything into a movie version of a book, and I am, for the most part, accepting of this. However, why is it that movie makers feel the need to change small things that are easier left as described in the book? Let me give an example that won’t spoil the movie, but will adequately demonstrate my point. Take Lord of the Rings, why did they not give Strider Isildur’s sword? That sword was Aragorn’s whole claim to be included in the fellowship, it was remade at Rivendell (In Fellowship of The Ring). Why would they re-write that? It would have been easier to keep it the way Tolkien had written it. You get the point, these are the types of things that annoy me in movie adaptations. There are several of these in the HP movies and, for me, they detract from the movie. I’ll discuss two of them next, but don’t worry I won’t give away anything from the movie.
Books six and seven are much darker than the first five books. HP&HBP, however, tries to keep things light as possible by balancing light-hearted teen romance and the dark nature of the story. Tom Felton does a great job playing the sulking Draco Malfoy, and Rupert Grint(Ron Weasly) has turned into a much more interesting person to watch than Daniel Radcliffe (Harry Potter). All-in-all the teens have really grown up and it shows well on screen, my only wish is that Ginny and Harry’s relationship would have had more screen time.
There are two main things that annoyed me about this movie, to the point where it detracted from my experience. These were problems with the last HP movie as well, and I expected them in this one. The first HP movie is one of the few movies (not just Harry Potter movies) that I think is as good if not better than the book. As Rawlings made her creation more elaborate, however, the movies began to leave things out. I would be ok with most of this except for two glaring problems. The first was unavoidable as a result of the passing of Richard Harris. I, for one, think that he was excellent as Dumbledore and his death was truly a tragedy for the franchise. Michael Gambon, who replaced Harris, simply doesn’t have the acting skill to be Dumbledore. I am constantly disappointed by his portrayal of the most powerful wizard in the world. I know this is on the fringe of what I should be dissapointed about in the movie, but it’s bothered me since Harris was replaced. This movie is no exception, even though I would have to say that HP&HBP gives us Gambon’s best performance yet it still is just not good enough.
The second thing that has bothered me for several movies is the change in art direction. The change in the portrayal of the dementors as well as people flying by turning into smoke are just a few of the distracting changes made in art direction. What is with people turning into smoke to fly? I will not demean the directory by asking if he read the books. Rawlings made a big point to mention that the only wizard ever able to fly without a broomstick or portkey was Voldemort, but I’m sure he read that part so I won’t ask. I know I’m being picky, but I want to see a wizard version of Christian Bale dualing like the gun battles in Equilibrium. Wizard duals that consist of smoke flying around on the screen with the random light flash is not what I was hoping for. I don’t want to see people turn into smoke and flying around the screen, its boring and goes against the ground rules created by Rawlings.
A note to parents: There has been a rash of movies this year which seem like they would be acceptable for children to watch, this is one of those movies–it’s rated PG and it comes from a famous kids book. I would not, however, recommended HP&HBP for the normal audience that goes to see PG movies. This movie is scary, and has some vary intense scenes. The general content does not warrant a PG-13 rating, but I would think twice before bringing young kids to this movie–especially if they are easily scared. Better yet, watch the movie first before taking the kids.
Bottom Line: For HP fans this is a movie worth seeing in the theater and DVD (my review wouldn’t stop you from going anyway so why try?).
This movie, as with most of the other HP movies, is only able to give part of the plot and depth that the books have and it lacks because of it. I think that Rawlings is not the best at crafting words, but her ideas are amazingly unique and she is a great story teller. The writers of the HP screenplays are not. Maybe they will bring out an amazing show for the last two movies (book seven is going to be split into two movies), but I’m not holding my breath. I enjoyed the movie for what it was and didn’t feel like my money was wasted.
I give HP&HBP a four smokey bad guys out of five.
That’s it for now.
-Zach